and now the screaming starts

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, 24 May 2010

Books: The lion, the witch, and the uncanny.

Posted on 10:16 by riya
I owe this find to my wife, who hipped me to this passage. Below, C. S. Lewis discusses the difference between fear, which he sees as an apprehension of danger, and dread, which he equates with the uncanny and a religious concept of the Numinous.

Aside from being an unexpected, but lucid voice in the on-going discussion about the varieties of horror, I also find Lewis's insights interesting for calling into question the common "just so" story that horror, as we now conceive of the emotion that fuels of genre entertainments, has some clear lineage to the psychological lives of ancient ancestors. While he doesn't doubt that our ancestors lived in demon-haunted worlds, he raises the question of whether one could conceive of supernatural forces when one hadn't conceived of a "natural" world. If everything is supernatural, isn't that your natural? And, if that's so, is the uncanny a fear of relatively recent vintage (in terms of the hundreds of thousands of years of human evolution)?

Here's Lewis from his The Problem of Pain:

Suppose you were told there was a tiger in the next room: you would know that you were in danger and would probably feel fear. But if you were told ‘There is a ghost in the next room’, and believed it, you would feel, indeed, what is often called fear, but of a different kind. It would not be based on the knowledge of danger, for no one is primarily afraid of what a ghost may do to him, but of the mere fact that it is a ghost. It is ‘uncanny’ rather than dangerous, and the special kind of fear it excites may be called Dread. With the Uncanny one has reached the fringes of the Numinous. Now suppose that you were told simply ‘There is a mighty spirit in the room’, and believed it. Your feelings would then be even less like the mere fear of danger: but the disturbance would be profound. You would feel wonder and a certain shrinking—a sense of inadequacy to cope with such a visitant and of prostration before it—an emotion which might be expressed in Shakespeare’s words ‘Under it my genius is rebuked’. This feeling may be described as awe, and the object which excites it as the Numinous.

Now nothing is more certain than that man, from a very early period, began to believe that the universe was haunted by spirits. Professor Otto [I have no idea who Otto is – CRwM] perhaps assumes too easily that from the very first such spirits were regarded with numinous awe. This is impossible to prove for the very good reason that utterances expressing awe of the Numinous and utterances expressing mere fear of danger may use identical language—as we can still say that we are ‘afraid’ of a ghost or ‘afraid’ of a rise in prices. It is there- fore theoretically possible that there was a time when men regarded these spirits simply as dangerous and felt towards them just as they felt towards tigers.

. . .

Now this awe is not the result of an inference from the visible universe. There is no possibility of arguing from mere danger to the uncanny, still less to the fully Numinous. You may say that it seems to you very natural that early man, being surrounded by real dangers, and therefore frightened, should invent the uncanny and the Numinous. In a sense it is, but let us understand what we mean. You feel it to be natural because, sharing human nature with your remote ancestors, you can imagine yourself reacting to perilous solitudes in the same way; and this reaction is indeed ‘natural’ in the sense of being in accord with human nature. But it is not in the least ‘natural’ in the sense that the idea of the uncanny or the Numinous is already contained in the idea of the dangerous, or that any perception of danger or any dislike of the wounds and death which it may entail could give the slightest conception of ghostly dread or numinous awe to an intelligence which did not already understand them. When man passes from physical fear to dread and awe, he makes a sheer jump, and apprehends something which could never be given, as danger is, by the physical facts and logical deductions from them. Most attempts to explain the Numinous presuppose the thing to be explained—as when anthropologists derive it from fear of the dead, without explaining why dead men (assuredly the least dangerous kind of men) should have attracted this peculiar feeling. Against all such attempts we must insist that dread and awe are in a different dimension from fear.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in books, Lewis, uncanny | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Art: It's a gasser!
    Not so long ago, the fine gentleman behind When Is Evil Cool? posted an image of a small crowd of English bobbies in gas masks. I commented...
  • Meta: Awards season.
    Seems like everybody is giving everybody awards these days. And, as living proof that surplus drives down value, even I've received one!...
  • Movies: Fangbanging in the BK.
    Brooklyn's own BAMcinématek has come up with a pretty good alternative to roasting outdoors and sweating your way through the dregs of t...
  • Movies: There's two sides to every global nuclear holocaust.
    This week marks the anniversary of the first record death by robot. On January 25, 1979, Flat Rock, Michigan, autoworker Robert Williams was...
  • Meta: Watch us pull an upset!
    Screamer, Screamettes, and the curious passersby, lend me your ears! Long time readers have probably figured out that I'm not a big ...
  • (no title)
    Neo-folkie Madeline - who was not, I think, named after one of the cats I grew up with, but I like to pretend that she was - has a video tha...
  • Stuff: The Jess List
    In my review of I Sell the Dead , I mentioned that my wife generally hates horror films. When she doesn't find them boring, she finds th...
  • Movies: I want to play a game, Part 3 - Don't everybody all volunteer at once.
    In this last post on what game theory can teach us about the Saw franchise, we're going to cover traps that involve three or more playe...
  • Movies: The second worst thing Bin Laden has ever done to us?
    What hath Kickstarter wrought? It's possible that you were tiring of the zombie craze. Perhaps you've got no more energy for a fast ...
  • Link Proliferation: "To join a cuib, an initiate had to suck the blood from self-imposed slashes in the arm of every other member of the nest."
    I totally flaked on this last Friday, but I meant to hip you to a great post by Zoe, the amazing blogger of the high strangeness that is Zo...

Categories

  • 10 Rillington Place
  • 16 horsepower
  • 2001 Maniacs
  • 2012
  • 2UN
  • a dark matter
  • a reliable wife
  • A-bones
  • abby
  • abrams
  • abu tubar
  • ackerman
  • ackroyd
  • aesop rock
  • africa
  • after dark films
  • Aja
  • aliens
  • all american werewolves
  • Alligator
  • alvin sputnik under sea explorer
  • american psycho
  • american werewolf in london
  • amish
  • anatomy of fear
  • anderson
  • animation
  • antosca
  • apocalypse
  • area 51
  • Argento
  • art
  • arthur
  • as in free you cheap bastards
  • Attenborough
  • Attery Squash
  • Audition
  • audrey's door
  • austen
  • Avatar
  • award
  • Aykroyd
  • babysitter wanted
  • Bacall
  • bacon
  • bad dog
  • baget
  • Balaguero
  • ball peen hammer
  • bara
  • Barker
  • barnes
  • bateman
  • bathory
  • bats
  • Battle Royale
  • Battle Royale 2
  • bauhaus
  • Bava
  • bear in heaven
  • Beatles
  • bed bugs
  • bedbugs
  • bergen street comics
  • Big Alligator River
  • bigfoot
  • bilal
  • biology
  • bitch slap
  • black death
  • black heart procession
  • black history month
  • black moth super rainbow
  • black swan
  • Blackhawk
  • blacula
  • Blitzen Trapper
  • blood creek
  • blood monkey
  • bonnie and clyde versus dracula
  • books
  • Bowie
  • boy detective
  • bradbury
  • breathers
  • Brooklyn
  • Brooklyn Industries
  • brooks
  • Browning
  • Burroughs
  • Burton
  • cabin fever 2 spring fever
  • cabinet of dr. caligari
  • cabrini-green
  • cadence weapon
  • cameron
  • Canada
  • candyman
  • Cannibal Holocaust
  • cannibals
  • captain chaos
  • captivity
  • Carpenter
  • Carroll
  • carter
  • casebook of victor frankenstein
  • castle
  • Castle in Transyvania
  • Castle of the Devil
  • cave
  • Chaney
  • children of the corn
  • chilton
  • chinsang
  • CIA
  • civil war
  • clair
  • clark
  • class of 1984
  • class of 1999
  • clothes
  • Cloverfield
  • cody
  • Cohen
  • combat garters
  • comics
  • Coney Island
  • contest
  • cooper
  • Corman
  • cornered
  • cornish
  • Count Chocula
  • courtesans
  • crap
  • Craven
  • crawford
  • crazy ray
  • creature feature
  • Creature from the Black Lagoon
  • creepy old people
  • crocodile
  • crosley
  • crothers
  • crowley
  • cryptids
  • Cthulhu
  • Cunningham
  • curtis
  • cuthbert
  • D and D
  • d-war
  • Dante
  • danzig
  • Darabont
  • darbont
  • Dark Horse
  • darnielle
  • david
  • dawn of the dead
  • de Védrines
  • Dead Alive
  • deadgirl
  • death ship
  • debbie gibson
  • deed
  • del Toro
  • deluise
  • demon
  • Department of Crazy Crap You Didn't Even Know You Had to Fear
  • depp
  • descent
  • descent 2
  • devil
  • Devo
  • dexter
  • dexter by design
  • dexter is delicious
  • diablo swing orchestra
  • Diary of the Dead
  • dinosaurs
  • documentary
  • doghouse
  • dolphin people
  • dougherty
  • douglas
  • dowdle
  • Dracula
  • Dracula 3000
  • dracula pages from a virgins diary
  • drag me to hell
  • dragons
  • drive-by truckers
  • dungeons and dragons
  • Ebert
  • economics
  • eel
  • el-hai
  • el-p
  • elliott
  • ellis
  • Elvira
  • emerson
  • endo is the bomb
  • evenson
  • evil children
  • evil corporations
  • evil mind museum
  • Exorcist
  • famous monsters of filmland
  • fanaka
  • fashion
  • fear response
  • feminine hygiene
  • ferguson
  • fessenden
  • fever ray
  • fillbach brothers
  • Fleischer
  • flimes
  • food
  • fox
  • francis
  • Franco
  • Frankenberry
  • Frankenstein
  • freaks
  • free stuff
  • Freud
  • freund
  • Friday the 13th
  • fright night
  • from here to eternity
  • Frontier(s)
  • fugue state
  • Fukasaku
  • funerals
  • furlong
  • future of the left
  • Gaiman
  • ganja and hess
  • gas masks
  • gay for johnny depp
  • gay marriage
  • gein
  • genie
  • george washington
  • Ghastly Ones
  • ghost
  • Ghostbusters
  • Ghoul a-Go-Go
  • GI Joe
  • giant monster
  • giant robots
  • gibson
  • Gierasch
  • girly
  • gladfelter
  • glass
  • glover
  • Godzilla
  • Godzilla Raids Again
  • goolrick
  • gorsuch
  • goth
  • gothic
  • grace
  • Grahame-Smith
  • grant
  • Greutert
  • grier
  • grover
  • guest blogger
  • guitar wolf
  • gunn
  • guru
  • guttenberg
  • ha ha tonka
  • Hall
  • halloween
  • hallucinations
  • handsome furs
  • Harel
  • Haring
  • harmon
  • harold and the purple crayon
  • harpes
  • harpoon
  • harrington
  • harryhausen
  • hauer
  • haunt of fear
  • haunted house ride
  • haunted spooks
  • haunted vagina
  • hayward
  • Hellraiser
  • Henseigh
  • hickenlooper
  • high plains invaders
  • high tension
  • Hill
  • Hills Have Eyes 2
  • history
  • hitcher
  • hoax
  • hodag
  • Homecoming
  • Hooper
  • Horn
  • horns
  • Hostel
  • Hostel 2
  • houdini
  • hough
  • house of silent scream
  • house of the devil
  • howard
  • howell
  • hunchback of notre dame
  • Hurt
  • hypnosis
  • I Am Legend
  • I Love Horror
  • i sell the dead
  • i walked with a zombie
  • imp of the perverse
  • improv everywhere
  • Inglourious Basterds
  • insects
  • inside
  • iraq
  • J-horror
  • jack the ripper
  • Jackson
  • Jacobson
  • Jaws
  • jennifers body
  • jigsaw
  • jim carroll
  • joffe
  • johnson
  • Jonah Hex
  • Jones
  • joy division
  • Jung
  • kafka
  • keach
  • kemp
  • kidman
  • Killenger
  • kim
  • King
  • King Kong
  • Kitamura
  • kraken
  • krol
  • kubba
  • kubrick
  • kusama
  • laid to rest
  • lake mungo
  • lampshade
  • land
  • landis
  • Lang
  • Langan
  • Lansdale
  • Last House on the Left
  • Last Winter
  • laugier
  • laymon
  • League of Tana Tea Drinkers
  • lecter
  • led zepplin
  • lee
  • legend of hell house
  • lennon
  • lester
  • let the right one in
  • Lewis
  • lindsay
  • link
  • link proliferation
  • liquid television
  • lliadis
  • lloyd
  • local natives
  • loch ness
  • London
  • London After Midnight
  • Lovecraft
  • lucha
  • mabuse the gambler
  • mad science
  • mad science; hunger; hentges; cannibals
  • maddin
  • magazine
  • magic
  • manasseri
  • manson
  • marebito
  • Mareva
  • Martino
  • martyrs
  • Marvel
  • masque of the red death
  • Mastandrea
  • Masters of Horror
  • mata hari
  • math
  • Matheson
  • maze
  • mcdowell
  • McEwen
  • mcgee
  • mclaren
  • mcquiad
  • medak
  • medean events
  • mega shark versus giant octopus
  • melville
  • mermaid heather
  • meta
  • meteor
  • metropolis
  • Meyer
  • Meyers
  • michael jackson
  • midnight meat train
  • midnight picnic
  • Miéville
  • miike
  • Miss Bugs
  • miss derringer
  • mixel pixel
  • monae
  • money
  • mongolian death worm
  • monkeys
  • monster mash
  • monster squad
  • monte
  • Moore
  • moreland
  • morrison
  • Morrow
  • movie
  • movie news
  • movie posters
  • movies
  • Mulholland
  • Mum and Dad
  • Mummies
  • mummy
  • murakami
  • murderabilia
  • Murnau
  • murphy
  • museum of death
  • music
  • My Barbarian
  • My Bloody Valentine
  • myrick
  • mystery team
  • nanotech
  • Nazi
  • Neanderthal
  • Neanderthals
  • neville
  • news
  • nick cave and the bad seeds
  • night of the demons
  • night of the living dead
  • Nightmare on Elm Street
  • nightmares
  • Nightwatch
  • nine inch nails
  • ninjas
  • Noe
  • nosferatu
  • nova
  • noxon
  • numan
  • NYC Comic Con
  • o'connor
  • obama
  • obamacare
  • Offspring
  • Opera
  • Ott
  • outbreak horror
  • outpost
  • over there
  • paranormal activity
  • park
  • parker
  • peli
  • pengin homosexuality
  • perlman
  • petty
  • Peyo
  • phifer
  • pigeons from hell
  • pink noise
  • piranha
  • pirates
  • pissing blood
  • plague
  • plan 9 from outer space
  • planet of the vampires
  • play
  • Plaza
  • plimptons
  • plum island
  • Plumtree
  • pod cast
  • Poe
  • poetry
  • porter
  • predator
  • predator 2
  • prehistory
  • pride and prejudice and zombies
  • Primeval
  • psychic
  • pulp fiction
  • punishment park
  • pym
  • quarantine
  • radio horror
  • raimi
  • randian
  • random picture
  • rapp
  • raw meat
  • real estate
  • rec
  • red dawn
  • red sands
  • red. del toro
  • religion
  • renfroe
  • rescued from an eagles nest
  • resident evil
  • reynolds
  • reznor
  • richards
  • rines
  • Ring
  • Ring II
  • RIP
  • ripley's believe or not
  • rival schools
  • Rob Zombie
  • robots
  • Rodriguez
  • romance novels
  • Romero
  • rose
  • Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Undead
  • Roth
  • run for your lives
  • RZA
  • sagoes
  • sala
  • sales
  • sand serpents
  • Sandman
  • santa muerte
  • santigold
  • Santo
  • Santo and the Border of Terror
  • Sariento
  • Sasquatch
  • satanism
  • Saw
  • saw 3D
  • saw 6
  • schorr
  • schrader
  • schumacher
  • sci-fi
  • scream
  • Screamin' Lord Sutch
  • scrotum
  • sea monster
  • sea wolf
  • seabrook
  • sendak
  • serial killers
  • Serrador
  • sex
  • sex pistols
  • shady
  • Shambling Towards Hiroshima
  • shark
  • sharktopus
  • Shimizu
  • shower
  • shutter island
  • Shwarzenegger
  • silence of the lambs
  • silent film
  • silent scream series
  • Simmons
  • sims
  • siouxsie and the banshees
  • Siouxsie Sioux
  • six string samurai
  • skeletons
  • skeptic
  • slang
  • slasher
  • slashers
  • Smith
  • smurfs
  • snuff
  • solet
  • solomon
  • Solomon Kane
  • Sondheim
  • soule
  • Southern Gothic
  • speed
  • Spotnicks
  • springsteen
  • stelarc
  • stewart
  • stick figure theater
  • Stine
  • stink ape
  • stocker
  • stockwell
  • stoker
  • strahm
  • straub
  • Stuff
  • Suicide Girls Must Die
  • sullivan
  • super 8
  • surf rock
  • survival of the dead
  • sweat
  • Sweeney Todd
  • t-shirts
  • Takami
  • Takeuchi
  • Tarantino
  • television
  • terminator
  • terri
  • Texas Chainsaw Massacre
  • the blaft anthology of tamil pulp fiction
  • the burrowers
  • the butcher
  • the cramps
  • the devil's daughter
  • the final
  • the fright biz
  • The Great Slasher Research Project of '10
  • the hills run red
  • the impaler
  • the mist
  • the new kids
  • The Number: 73304-23-4153-6-96-8
  • the objective
  • the roberts
  • The Ruins
  • the sadist
  • the screwfly solution
  • the shining
  • the South will sit tight again
  • the sprites
  • The Thing
  • the ugly
  • the walking dead
  • the washingtonians
  • the woods are dark
  • them
  • these united states
  • Thirst
  • tiger
  • time travel
  • to kill a mockingbird
  • torture
  • torture porn
  • Tourneur
  • Toxic Avenger
  • triangle
  • trick r treat
  • trigger man
  • troggs
  • troop
  • tru blood
  • true blood
  • true crime
  • true horror stories
  • turistas
  • Turner
  • Twilight
  • Unbelievable
  • uncanny
  • Uncle Strangley's Dark Mansion of Big Crap Scares
  • under-utilized nightmares
  • Unity Post
  • vamp
  • vampire
  • verne
  • Ving Rhames for Secretary of Pussy
  • vonnegut
  • voodoo
  • watchmen
  • waters
  • watt
  • we will bury you
  • welcome home brother charles
  • welcome to the jungle
  • weller
  • wereshark
  • werewolf
  • werewolves on the moon versus vampires
  • west
  • what horror movie are we today
  • where the wild things are
  • white
  • white denim
  • who can kill a child
  • wild zero
  • Williams
  • winters
  • witches
  • women in prison
  • won
  • woolite
  • World War Z
  • wrestlemaniac
  • wright
  • wrightson
  • x-mas
  • yeah yeah yeahs
  • yeti
  • you say party we say die
  • young
  • yuck
  • zombie strippers
  • zombie survival guide recorded attacks
  • zombieland
  • zombies

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (1)
    • ►  January (1)
  • ►  2012 (5)
    • ►  December (1)
    • ►  July (1)
    • ►  April (2)
    • ►  February (1)
  • ►  2011 (53)
    • ►  December (1)
    • ►  November (2)
    • ►  October (4)
    • ►  September (1)
    • ►  August (5)
    • ►  July (7)
    • ►  June (5)
    • ►  April (4)
    • ►  March (11)
    • ►  February (8)
    • ►  January (5)
  • ▼  2010 (172)
    • ►  December (4)
    • ►  November (6)
    • ►  October (11)
    • ►  September (7)
    • ►  August (12)
    • ►  July (14)
    • ►  June (16)
    • ▼  May (20)
      • Stuff: The Jess List
      • Contest: Because other blog fandoms are Tokyo and ...
      • Stuff: George Romero pulls an evil Captain Kirk fr...
      • Movies: Don't worry, you play the German doctor guy.
      • Stuff: “Scaled, forked-tongued Lizarde Men from th...
      • Movies: Ain't no sin in Cincinnati.
      • Books: The lion, the witch, and the uncanny.
      • Comics: All aboard that's going aboard.
      • Stuff: Bustin' still makes them feel good . . .
      • Movies: Turning tricks.
      • Movies: That funky monkey.
      • Stuff: "Dig down far enough into this oogly-googly...
      • Movies: 1) Collect dead, 2) ?, 3) profit.
      • Stuff: Sympathy for the poor devil.
      • Real estate: Looking for a place to wait out the z...
      • Comics: My mash-up pitch? I'm going to put vampire...
      • Music: Lux and Ivy's Favorites
      • Movies: The one I would save.
      • Stuff: Praying to death.
      • Movies: "B" average.
    • ►  April (20)
    • ►  March (14)
    • ►  February (27)
    • ►  January (21)
  • ►  2009 (269)
    • ►  December (17)
    • ►  November (21)
    • ►  October (28)
    • ►  September (26)
    • ►  August (33)
    • ►  July (23)
    • ►  June (23)
    • ►  May (28)
    • ►  April (31)
    • ►  March (27)
    • ►  February (12)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

riya
View my complete profile